The highly controversial Movie Star bracket is back, and this time it moves up yet another decade to determine the Best Movie Star in Their 40s! Art and Zach get some help from Elliott of Movie Files to assess the careers are Hollywood's hottest stars and starlets. Out of all of these Oscar-winners, box office champions, and internet favorites, whose star burns the brightest? The full bracket template is available on our social media accounts! Download a copy and send us your results.

Check out the Best Movie Stars Under 30 - https://youtu.be/E7_2FYaaheI

Check out the Best Movie Stars in Their 30s - https://youtu.be/zYJSNwUycQ4

TIMECODES…

00:00 - Intro

02:01 - What makes a 'Movie Star'?

06:35 - Actors too young or old

08:49 - Who didn't make the cut?

14:44 - Elisabeth Moss vs. Rebecca Hall

19:06 - Eddie Redmayne vs. Chris Evans

20:57 - Natalie Portman vs. Rami Malek

24:34 - Jake Gyllenhaal vs. Ryan Gosling

26:41 - Channing Tatum vs. Jason Momoa

31:56 - Chris Pratt vs. Oscar Isaac

36:30 - Rosamund Pike vs. Tom Hardy

38:30 - Michael Fassbender vs. Jessica Chastain

41:53 - Ryan Reynolds vs. Benedict Cumberbatch

45:03 - Colin Farrell vs. Reese Witherspoon

48:31 - Kate Winslet vs. Charlize Theron

51:52 - Pedro Pascal vs. Bradley Cooper

55:49 - Leonardo Dicaprio vs. Joaquin Phoenix

59:29 - Amy Adams vs. Michael Shannon

1:03:44 - Penelope Cruz vs. Mahershala Ali

1:06:49 - Christian Bale vs. Toni Collette

1:10:28 - Sweet Sixteen

1:25:24 - Elite Eight

1:37:23 - Finale Four

1:42:19 - The Best Movie Star in their 40's

1:46:00 - Final Thoughts